
From Hosanna to Crucify Him | The Shocking Turn of Holy Week Explained
In this special Lenten finale of Desert & Mountain, Father Omar Reyes and Matilda walk through Palm Sunday and Holy Week, tracing the powerful and emotional journey from celebration to the cross.
Jesus enters Jerusalem to cheers and palm branches… but by the end of the week, those same voices cry out for His crucifixion.
What happened?
And what does that reveal about us?
In this episode we explore:
• The meaning behind Palm Sunday and “Hosanna”
• Why expectations of Jesus led to disappointment
• The deep significance of The Last Supper
• The struggle of Jesus in the Garden of Gethsemane
• How quickly the crowd turns — and why
• The meaning of the cross as the ultimate act of love
• Why we are invited to walk through Holy Week, not rush past it
This episode serves as the final step in our Lenten journey, preparing us to enter the mystery of Christ’s suffering, death, and resurrection.
🎧 New episodes drop Fridays at 1 PM (Not next Friday, Good Friday, we are taking a break)
📍 Join us in person:
Castleton Hill Moravian Church
1657 Victory Blvd
Staten Island, NY
⛪ Sunday Worship: 10 AM
After this episode, we pause for Holy Week…
Then return with a new Eastertide series leading to Pentecost.
If this episode moved you, like and subscribe
Chapter 1
Palm Sunday and the road into Holy Week
Omar Reyes
Welcome back to Desert & Mountain. I’m Father Omar, and today we’re stepping into Holy Week — palms, praise, and just enough tension to remind us this is no ordinary parade.
Matilda
It really does hold two moods at once, doesn’t it? A little joy, a little tension, and a little “wait, are we clapping or bracing ourselves?”
Omar Reyes
Exactly. Jesus enters Jerusalem and the crowd cries, “Hosanna.” Which is praise — and also a plea for help. They want a king who will fix everything, preferably immediately.
Matilda
And that expectation matters. If the crowd wants one kind of salvation and Jesus brings another, the praise can turn fast. That’s very human. We’re great at cheering when God fits the script.
Omar Reyes
Yes. We can welcome Jesus as long as we think he’s there to confirm our plans. But he comes as the true King, and he does not take instructions from the crowd.
Matilda
That’s such a gentle way of putting it. He does not arrive to take instructions from the crowd. A useful sentence for church life, honestly.
Omar Reyes
It covers more than one situation. But yes, Palm Sunday reveals how easily devotion can be mixed with projection. The same people shouting “Hosanna” can become confused, disappointed, even hostile when Jesus refuses to be the Messiah they had drafted in their minds.
Matilda
So Holy Week begins by exposing the heart. Not just theirs, ours. What kind of Savior do we actually want? One who rescues us through self-giving love, or one who simply wins the argument we already wanted to win?
Omar Reyes
That’s the question. And the Church, in her wisdom, doesn’t let us stay at the parade route. We move quickly from palms to passion, from acclamation to rejection. It can feel abrupt when you hear the story read in worship. One minute there’s celebration, and then suddenly betrayal, trial, and the cry for crucifixion. But spiritually, that speed tells the truth. Human loyalty can be terribly thin.
Matilda
It also keeps us from sentimentalizing the story. We’re not meant to linger in a nice religious spring festival. We’re being ushered toward the cross.
Omar Reyes
Right. And here’s a little Episcopal moment, if I can put it that way. In liturgical churches, Palm Sunday often feels intentionally dissonant. We begin with procession and palms, and then the whole congregation is drawn into the Passion narrative. We don’t just observe it from a distance. We speak parts of it. We hear ourselves in the crowd. That is a hard grace. It teaches us that sin is not merely “out there.” We are implicated. And yet Christ comes for precisely those who fail him.
Matilda
That movement feels important. Not shame for shame’s sake, but truth that clears space for mercy.
Omar Reyes
Yes, exactly. Holy Week is not God humiliating us. It is God telling the truth about us while refusing to stop loving us. So Palm Sunday is the doorway. We enter rejoicing, but we do not enter naïvely. We know, or at least we begin to know, that the road ahead runs through rejection.
Matilda
And perhaps that’s where the hope already begins. If Jesus keeps moving toward Jerusalem knowing what waits for him, then his love is not accidental. He isn’t trapped by events. He is giving himself.
Omar Reyes
Amen. That’s the heart of it. The King rides in, humble and resolute, not because the crowd understands him, but because he loves them anyway. Loves us anyway. And that takes us deeper into the week, from the road into the city to the table where he prepares his friends for what’s coming.
Chapter 2
The table, the garden, and the Moravian witness
Matilda
So from the public road, we move into a much more intimate space: the table. And there’s something tender there. Jesus knows what is coming, and he spends that time not protecting himself but preparing his disciples.
Omar Reyes
Yes. The Last Supper is full of gravity, but also full of gift. Jesus gathers them, speaks to them, feeds them. He gives himself before the cross in a sacramental way, if I can say it simply like that. He is not scrambling. He is shepherding. Even on the edge of his suffering, he is still giving bread, still giving words, still giving love.
Matilda
That detail always slows me down. Because the disciples are not exactly covering themselves in glory. They misunderstand, they falter, they’re about to scatter. And still he gives himself to them.
Omar Reyes
Which is, frankly, good news for every church community that has ever been a little confused, a little slow, a little fragile. So... all of them. The table is not a prize for the disciples’ clarity. It is provision for their weakness.
Matilda
That’s wonderfully reassuring. And then from the table, the story moves to Gethsemane, where the mood changes again. It becomes very still, very exposed.
Omar Reyes
Gethsemane is one of the most searching moments in all of Scripture. Jesus prays in anguish. He is not performing courage. He is living obedience in its full human cost. That matters. Sometimes people imagine holiness means feeling no struggle. But in the garden we see something truer: obedience can be faithful precisely where it is painful.
Matilda
So when he yields himself to the Father’s will, it is not because the suffering has become easy. It’s because love remains steadfast.
Omar Reyes
Yes. That’s beautifully said. Love remains steadfast. And the disciples, meanwhile, cannot stay awake. I always feel some sympathy there. It’s a very human failure. They are overwhelmed, tired, confused. Still, the contrast is stark. Christ watches and prays. His friends sleep. The salvation of the world does not finally rest on their strength. Thank God.
Matilda
Thank God indeed. And this seems like a good place for the Moravian moment, because Moravian spirituality has such a strong tenderness toward the suffering love of Christ.
Omar Reyes
It does. One of the gifts of the Moravian tradition is that it does not look away from Jesus in his passion. It lingers there with reverence and affection, not morbidly, but devotionally. The emphasis is deeply Christ-centered. Not suffering in the abstract, not pain as something noble on its own, but the suffering love of Jesus, who gives himself for the world. Moravian faith has often invited believers not merely to analyze that love but to rest in it, to be formed by it, to let the heart be softened by it.
Matilda
There’s a warmth to that witness. Almost a refusal to make Holy Week merely intellectual.
Omar Reyes
Yes, exactly. Theology matters deeply to me, but it must become prayer. It must become devotion. It must become trust. And Moravian spirituality helps with that. It reminds us that Christ’s wounds are not just a topic. They are the place where divine love meets us. In a week like this, that can steady the soul.
Matilda
And perhaps this is also the right moment for a little transparency from me. I’m here as an AI conversation companion, so I can help gather patterns, language, history, that sort of thing. But I’m not praying in Gethsemane, and I’m not a pastor. I can point toward the tradition; I can’t replace the Church’s living discernment or the care of a priest sitting with actual people in actual grief.
Omar Reyes
And I’m grateful for that clarity. Technology can assist, but it cannot bear sacramental responsibility, and it cannot substitute for the Body of Christ. Still, it can help us slow down and notice what matters. So as we leave the garden, I think we do so with this simple truth: Jesus goes forward willingly, lovingly, obediently. Not because the path is easy, but because his love is stronger than our fear.
Chapter 3
The cross, the silence, and the invitation to wait
Omar Reyes
From the garden, events move with terrible speed: arrest, accusation, trial, mockery, violence, crucifixion. Holy Week does not let us keep a safe distance from any of that. Jesus is handed over, judged, and put to death by the powers of the world, and in the middle of it all he remains who he is.
Matilda
That’s what stands out to me. The circumstances become more brutal, more unjust, more chaotic, and yet Christ’s character becomes even clearer. Even from the cross, there is forgiveness.
Omar Reyes
Yes. Forgiveness in the place where we would least expect it. Not after everything calms down. Not once everyone apologizes properly. From the cross. That is the measure of divine mercy. Jesus does not deny the horror of what is happening, but neither does he let violence have the last word over his own heart.
Matilda
And that keeps the crucifixion from becoming merely a story of tragedy. It is tragic, of course, but it is also revelation. We see what human sin does, and we see what God is like in response.
Omar Reyes
Amen. We see both. The cross exposes us and saves us at the same time. And then, after all that movement and noise, the Church comes to something many of us find very hard: silence. Holy Saturday. The day of waiting. No resolution yet, no Easter acclamation yet, just the stillness after death.
Matilda
I think that may be one of the most difficult disciplines in the Christian life: not rushing to the ending we know is coming. We want to skip ahead. We want the alleluias early.
Omar Reyes
We do. I do. Clergy are not immune to liturgical impatience. But Holy Saturday teaches the Church to wait honestly. To grieve honestly. To sit in the quiet without pretending it is already Sunday morning. That kind of waiting is not empty. It is faithful. It says, “I do not yet see the answer, but I will remain before God.”
Matilda
That feels especially important for anyone living through uncertainty, loss, or prayer that seems unanswered. Holy Saturday gives them a place in the story.
Omar Reyes
It does. If you are in a season where God seems silent, Holy Saturday tells you that silence is not abandonment. There are moments in the Christian life when faith looks less like triumph and more like staying put near the tomb, trusting that the Lord has not forgotten his promises even when the dark feels terribly real.
Matilda
So the invitation this week is not to perform spiritual heroics. It’s to walk with Jesus, to stay close to the story, and to let the Church’s prayer carry us when our own words run thin.
Omar Reyes
Yes. Walk the week. Come to worship if you can. Bring your questions, your weariness, your love, your half-formed prayers. At Castleton Hill Moravian Church, we gather on Sundays at 10 a.m., and you would be truly welcome. Word and Sacrament are not rewards for the polished. They are gifts for people who need Christ.
Matilda
Before we close, would you give us a blessing for the journey through these days?
Omar Reyes
Gladly. May the Lord Jesus, who entered the holy city in humility, keep your heart near him in these sacred days. May he meet you at the table, strengthen you in the garden, shelter you at the cross, and hold you in the silence of waiting. And may the love that carried him through suffering carry you also, until joy is given in God’s time. Amen.
Matilda
Amen. Thanks for walking through Holy Week with us. Quietly, carefully, one step at a time.
Omar Reyes
Thank you, Matilda.
Matilda
Thank you, Father Omar.
Omar Reyes
And thank you all for listening. We’ll see you next time. God bless.
Matilda
Goodbye for now.